1 (edited by joomong 2015-11-06 00:14:23)

Topic: Korean war bow

Here are some pictures of Korean war bow in Museum, Paris.
As you can see here, the siyah is different, and the limb is not just flat, like current Korean bows.  The middle limbs are the widest, about 4.2cm. 

http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p120/gorillajin/a0114898_4dd54e938f3c6.jpg

http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p120/gorillajin/a0114898_4ddddebf20134.jpg

http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p120/gorillajin/a0114898_4ddddeb1d8e1f.jpg

http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p120/gorillajin/chiwoo_quiver-2.jpg

http://i126.photobucket.com/albums/p120/gorillajin/a0114898_4dd54ebda6f77.jpg

Thumbs up

2 (edited by Pedro C 2017-03-22 09:27:27)

Re: Korean war bow

Cool, I imagine it could be used with medium(medium-light?) to heavy arrows?
Any idea what the string material is? [edit: it's most likely silk. apparently 3-ply twisted.. ...)
That's a hell of a lot of reflex. Would be great to see one strung and drawn

Re: Korean war bow

Pedro C wrote:

Cool, I imagine it could be used with medium(medium-light?) to heavy arrows?
Any idea what the string material is?
That's a hell of a lot of reflex. Would be great to see one strung and drawn

I want to see it strung too.  I do not know what is the material of string.  Back in the day, archers shot over 100lbs bows so I guess arrows must be at least medium to heavy arrows.

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

What a monster! In another thread people seem very dismissive of the idea that bows certainly developed down through the ages. Maybe these siyahs served a similar purpose to the Manchu type bow of recent past? That would indicate long, heavy arrows and perhaps shooting afoot. After the advent of firearms the bow was mainly used for rapid fire short distance combat so who knows how old this is?

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

Because it's wider, and has heavier siyahs compare to modern Korean target bows, the war bow's shooting distance might be shorter, and might be slower too.  However, it's more stable, will not twist easily, and shoot heavier arrows.

Thumbs up

6 (edited by Pedro C 2016-10-19 23:16:32)

Re: Korean war bow

can't read Korean

http://egloos.zum.com/sosohi/v/10712953
http://egloos.zum.com/sosohi/v/11076378
http://www.archerynews.net/news/view.as … p;idx=1150

https://i.imgur.com/mqJSPHB.jpg

Wow, quite monstruous. Wonder how long it is, draw weight and how long it'd be drawn..

Narrowing limbs & kasan, horn ending in middle or maybe even before kasan, looks like great design. So much reflex in the bending limbs though... not much reflex at kasan eye?..

Seems like it could have more problems with twist than the Turkish/Tatar bows, dunno. But it also seems like it would be both very fast and store lots of energy

7 (edited by Pedro C 2017-03-22 11:03:12)

Re: Korean war bow

The hornbowyer Jj Weißnicht did this reproduction of that bow, 60#@32". He estimated the original bow's draw weight at around 100#.

https://i.imgur.com/Z3c5GlH.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/fv9G2jL.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/EK1DAnE.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/1jzyrzr.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/glhTLVb.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/fLrOVn9.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/RqWruIi.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/gVJMgvB.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/uvtdc0o.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/PwOOgeq.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/NbViOkg.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/T6J9WVo.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/YiMJX8F.jpg

Re: Korean war bow

bonus

https://i.imgur.com/qVdoxhW.jpg

Re: Korean war bow

So I understand that this is the 'actual' Korean war bow but what time time frame was it used in? Joseon era?  Goryeo? etc.

Also, I believe the gakgung typically sold today was standardized more around 1500 AD if not mistaken?  But in actuality its more of a flight bow rather than one used in combat?  Or was it used in combat?

So many questions....

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

geoarcher wrote:

So I understand that this is the 'actual' Korean war bow but what time time frame was it used in? Joseon era?  Goryeo? etc.

Also, I believe the gakgung typically sold today was standardized more around 1500 AD if not mistaken?  But in actuality its more of a flight bow rather than one used in combat?  Or was it used in combat?

So many questions....

bluelake, any thoughts on this?

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

geoarcher wrote:

But in actuality its more of a flight bow rather than one used in combat?

Did Koreans engage in a kind of flight shooting at that time, comparable to Ottomans ?
Or was it just comparatively speaking ?

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

ragnar wrote:

Did Koreans engage in a kind of flight shooting at that time, comparable to Ottomans ?
Or was it just comparatively speaking ?

Not sure.  That's also why I'm trying to figure out the time frame of the war bow's use.  If its Joseon era then it was likely used up until the time archery for combat becomes obsolete. Therefore the logic, the way I see it, is 'if that's the war bow proper then what we typically see today is/was not'.  And had a different use/purpose.  Flight shooting is something that seems to exist in older times so long as you have a noblitiy/upper-class that wanted something leisurely to do.  And that's really I can say about that.

I will reiterate though that I am ultimately not sure and clarification is much needed here.

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

Yes, would be nice if someone knowledgable could shed some light on it.

Flight shooting is something that seems to exist in older times so long as you have a noblitiy/upper-class that wanted something leisurely to do.

Except for the Ottomans, I know no other culture that engaged in flight shooting. And considering that fact that archery was and is about hitting a target, the archery-related recreational pursuits reflected that. Most competitions were rather precision related. And arrow weights below 200 grain don't imply any military significance.
But the fact remains, the traditional Korean bow is one of the very few historical designs that allow for such an endeavor with similar results, and without breaking at this tiny gpp ratios.

Unfortunately I depend on translations for historical research - the fundamentally different language/script provide a high entrance barrier ...

Thumbs up

14 (edited by geoarcher 2019-04-30 21:02:24)

Re: Korean war bow

Anyway, so I did my own poking around and according to this reputable bowyer who is making one of these Korean war bows, they are in fact Joseon era:

https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set … mp;__xts__[0]=68.ARBuPssKd8i3nglSx2-TQR5nUyLzQ-3uqaiftyRMu_RPQwHWTvW_ZiIyk6hBG_t1oSo4jHFuvXi6ZfaRN8UVKlVainvewd_SrxV9VjHUhBep8Jzz5u5ajOzbQ8RnNczt9MRcORomdZtTsCNDB1g8KdtUAcS_4zvACxXpvdb1v3e-oFVCU6lDovmA6qgbQ17jYL_vdrRmIsQPAXWgfTKckrdY-bj-JEjIo43S-KvWK8CTKEWRD2_OIwm-SaggYgK7CAM-95U9-npeptpFIpvccQYanCxP16J9XDFUjDpA672jimm3xmkw44BZ2q7tZtbjV5iFW9AR8jnvGlsZd9P5KSfuu10CZ-C29hSr7rhPi73-7QWk38iEW-CUW0-5MTLSSZaUGQtBr9qLsYqvY3cyy0X36-D5cT7AulOOFP4vBoF3DwQgK4zi_oZmNiSyzZXV8E-3IZ_dMhNJN57BwNKA&__tn__=HH-R

Which I kinda suspected anyway.....

Thumbs up +1

Re: Korean war bow

Higher preload, and higher power at less mass weight.
Traditional turkish/ottoman bows are very similar in this regard.

Thumbs up

Re: Korean war bow

On a side note, Koreans do apparently practice a type of flight shooting.  Except its known as 'far shooting' in the language: 멀리 쏘기.  Usually done on long sandy beaches.

Footage: http://blog.daum.net/woo-139/257

Thumbs up